Best Five Guys Milkshake: Flavors, Ingredients, Recipe & Price

If you love burgers and fries, the best Five Guys milkshake probably sits right next to them in your order. The shakes are thick, creamy, hand-spun, and loaded with free mix-ins. That combination turns a simple dessert into a custom treat and keeps people searching for their own best Five Guys milkshake flavor.

The good news is simple. You can copy the texture, flavor, and mix-in style at home with the right Five Guys milkshake ingredients and a reliable blender. You keep the same indulgent feel, try new combinations, and save serious money compared to the regular Five Guys milkshake price.

---

Strawberry and Chocolate: Key Milkshake Ingredients

Two of the most loved variations use strawberry and chocolate. That is where your supporting keywords and flavor ideas come in.

Five Guys Strawberry Milkshake Ingredients

To mirror Five Guys strawberry milkshake ingredients, use:

• Vanilla ice cream
• Whole milk
• Fresh or frozen strawberries
• Strawberry syrup or puree
• Whipped cream and extra strawberry pieces for garnish

The real fruit plus syrup gives a bright color and a strong aroma. When you pour it into a chilled glass, the result comes very close to the in-store best Five Guys milkshake in strawberry form.

Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake Ingredients

For a chocolate version, your Five Guys chocolate milkshake ingredients look like this:

• Vanilla ice cream
• Whole milk
• Chocolate syrup
• Cocoa powder
• Optional chocolate chips or shaved chocolate

Cocoa powder deepens the flavor, while syrup gives that smooth dessert feel. Together they deliver a chocolate take on the best Five Guys milkshake that will satisfy any chocoholic.

Easy Copycat Five Guys Milkshake Recipe (Base)

The following Five Guys milkshake recipe gives you the perfect base. From that base, you can build every twist, including your favorite best milkshake combinations.

Classic Vanilla Copycat

Ingredients

• 3 large scoops vanilla ice cream
• ¾–1 cup cold whole milk
• 1–2 tablespoons sugar or vanilla syrup (optional)
• Whipped cream for topping

Method

1. Place a tall glass in the freezer to chill.
2. Add ice cream and ¾ cup milk to your blender.
3. Blend until thick and smooth. If the shake is too thick to pour, add a little more milk.
4. Taste and adjust sweetness with sugar or syrup.
5. Pour into the chilled glass and finish with whipped cream.

This simple base already tastes like a plain version of the best Five Guys milkshake. From here, you just add flavor and experiment the same way you would with other drinks

Five Guys Strawberry Milkshake Recipe

You can now turn the base into a Five Guys strawberry milkshake recipe.

Ingredients

• Classic vanilla base
• ½–¾ cup strawberries (fresh or frozen)
• 2 tablespoons strawberry syrup or puree

Method

1. Blend the vanilla base until smooth.
2. Add strawberries and syrup.
3. Blend until the shake turns pink and no large fruit chunks remain.
4. Pour, top with whipped cream, and add strawberry slices.

You get a fruity, creamy version of the best Five Guys milkshake with a strong berry hit.

Five Guys Chocolate Milkshake Recipe

To follow a chocolate-forward Five Guys milkshake recipe, start again from the base.

Ingredients

• Classic vanilla base
• 3 tablespoons chocolate syrup
• 1 tablespoon cocoa powder
• Small handful of chocolate chips (optional)

Method

1. Blend the vanilla base.
2. Add chocolate syrup and cocoa and blend again.
3. If you like texture, pulse in chocolate chips at the end.
4. Pour into a chilled glass and top with whipped cream and shaved chocolate.

Rich, thick, and glossy, this version earns its spot as a serious candidate for the best Five Guys milkshake you can make at home.

How to Make a Five Guys Bacon Milkshake

Few menu items get as much attention as the Five Guys bacon milkshake. The sweet-savory combo sounds strange until you try it. After that, the mix of crispy bacon and vanilla often lands on people’s personal best milkshake combinations list.

Five Guys Bacon Milkshake Recipe

Here’s a home-friendly Five Guys bacon milkshake recipe.

Ingredients

• Classic vanilla milkshake base
• 2–3 slices crispy bacon, cooled and crumbled
• 1–2 tablespoons maple or caramel syrup
• Extra bacon bits for garnish

Method

1. Cook bacon until crisp, then drain on paper and let it cool.
2. Blend your vanilla base with maple or caramel syrup.
3. Stir most of the bacon pieces into the shake by hand (so they stay crunchy).
4. Pour into a glass, top with whipped cream, and finish with extra bacon.

You now have a real Five Guys milkshake with bacon. It might not be an everyday drink, but for some fans, this is the one and only best Five Guys milkshake.

Best Milkshake Combinations Inspired by Five Guys

Because mix-ins are free in many locations, customers constantly look for the best milkshake combinations and share them online. Use your base to test ideas like:

• Peanut butter + chocolate + banana
• Strawberry + Oreo
• Coffee + salted caramel + chocolate
• Vanilla + cherry + malt
• Bacon + caramel + vanilla

Keep one main flavor and one or two supporting flavors. That balance stops your best Five Guys milkshake from turning into a muddy, overly sweet blend.

Five Guys Milkshake Price vs Homemade Cost

The Five Guys milkshake price shifts by market. In many places, a single shake can sit in the $6–$8 (or similar local currency) range once tax and extras hit. If you order the best Five Guys milkshake every time you visit, the cost adds up fast.

Meanwhile, a tub of quality ice cream, a carton of milk, and a couple of syrups can give you 8–10 homemade shakes for not much more than a few store-bought cups. You copy the best Five Guys milkshake, control ingredients, and still have budget left for burgers or other sides.

FAQ: Best Five Guys Milkshake

What is the best Five Guys milkshake flavor?

Taste is personal, but popular picks for the best Five Guys milkshake include strawberry with Oreo, chocolate with peanut butter, and the bacon milkshake with caramel.

How many shake flavors are at Five Guys?

Most locations offer a vanilla base plus 10–13 mix-ins, which create dozens of Five Guys shake flavors and combinations in practice.

Can I make Five Guys milkshakes without dairy?

Yes. You can swap dairy ice cream and milk for plant-based versions. The result will not be exactly the same, but you can still follow any Five Guys milkshake recipe here and enjoy similar flavors.

Final Thoughts

If you want the best Five Guys milkshake without leaving your kitchen, focus on three steps:

1. Nail the base using quality Five Guys milkshake ingredients.
2. Learn the classic moves with a strawberry, chocolate, and bacon shake so you can compare each to the original.
3. Build your own best milkshake combinations from the same structure and adjust to your taste.

Once you have a few successful batches, you might decide the real best Five Guys milkshake is the one you just blended at home. For more homemade drink ideas, visit Wasabi Mixer and keep experimenting with new flavors.